Sunday, 25 December 2011

Does the country listens to you Common Man.


In response to the article " Two wrongs do not make a right".

In response to the article in the famous news paper “The Hindu” on the 13th of December, quoting their article 
"Rich urged to get LPG at Market price" I had written on the fuel prices in the country.

No surprise I did not receive any comment in FB.
No surprise the news paper “The Hindu” also did not bother to either mark an abuse, or a regret message or a write even few words on this.

In today’s news paper “The Hindu” in the BUSINESS REVIEW, there is an article
“Two Wrongs do not make a right” where in the first paragraph itself they have mentioned the same. You know why this article appeared in the news paper? Simply because the person who said this “The Head of a well known non-banking finance company”

Today’s article in the Hindu
Some weeks ago during a social dinner chat, the head of a well known non-banking finance company headquartered in Chennai made an interesting comment. The subject was fuel pricing and the distortions in the economy caused by the widening gap between petrol and diesel prices. This gentleman, seeking to buy an upmarket car, went to one of the dealerships that his group owned but had to return empty handed because all the cars there were diesel models. He wanted to buy a petrol model and the reason he gave was striking: “How is it right for me to buy a luxury diesel car and pay Rs.45 a litre for fuel when the average Indian pays Rs.70 a litre for petrol to fuel his Rs.40,000 two-wheeler?''
My Article in face book and also the same mailed to The Hindu
This article is a just a thought about on the Fuel Price in India and how it feels about it. I am giving importance to the lower income group and the middle income group because of the economic constraints and their capacity to earn irrespective of their Religion or Cast. Absolutely no discrimination to who he / she is.
The below table give the prices of few vehicles starting from a small Two Wheeler Pep to a very high priced Car Audi. This list is just an example to show variation, there are cars selling in India which costs much more than what is listed below so also the two wheelers.
  
S.No.                               Make & Model                                                       Approximate Price
1               Audi A8 L 3.0 TDI Quattro                                                                          77,85,268
2               Hyundai Santro Xing Non-AC                                                                      2,84,396
3               Maruti Suzuki 800 Std BS-III                                                                        1,99,900
4               Tata Nano CX                                                                                               1,76,548
5               Honda City  1.5 V AT Exclusive                                                                  10,00,889
6               Ford Fiesta Classic - SXi 1.4 TDCi                                                               8,31,715
7               Hyundai Accent  Executive LPG                                                                   5,46,421
8               Hindustan Motors Ambassador Classic 2000 DSZ AC PS                           5,10,229
9               Bajaj Kawasaki Ninja                                                                                    4,57,000
10             Royal Enfield Thunderbird Twinspark Price in India                                   1,03,000
11             Royal Enfield Bullet Electra 5S Price in India                                                 75,000
12             Hero Impulse 150cc                                                                                        66,800
13             TVS Wego                                                                                                      51,000
14             Bajaj Discover                                                                                                 46,000
15             Kinetic Nova 135 Price in Chennai:                                                                45,300
16             TVS Pep                                                                                                         40,000
17             Hero Honda CD Dawn                                                                                    35,000
18             Mahindra Kine Price in India                                                                           30,000


Group A
Now let’s consider who owns a Scooty or a so called Moped; these are people who earn very little compared to those who owns the big posh cars.
Group B
And then there are people who own slightly higher range say a 100cc Mobike (very difficult here again because the price starts from as low as Rs.40,000 to as high as Rs.1,00,000 and much more. Here the earning is probably better than the Group A
Group C
And then there are people who own small car, and the price starts from as low as Rs.1,75,000 to  Rs.3,00,000. Here the earning is probably better than the Group B or probably and so on.

And then starts the Higher Middle income, Higher Income Group and then Very High Income Group who can afford bigger cars and so on. Having said this there is clear affordability factor which is becoming obvious.  

Let’s take examples
1)     A person who owns a Moped (bought it probably for Rs.35000 to Rs40,000) earns as little as  say Rs.25,000
2)     The CEO of a Rs.2000 Crore company, his salary is around Rs.25,00,000, and owns a BMW or AUDI or BENZ.
Both pay Rs.70/per liter for petrol. Why we should not differentiate between the Lower Income Group who owns Moped and a Big Posh Car.
Another very important thing which we all know, the bigger cars consume more fuel and are cause for the depletion of our Natural resources.

I am trying to say that if a person can own a Posh, Costly & also consume large amount of fuel let the owner pay more for the Fuel he uses. If he can afford to spend say Rs.25,00,000 for buying such a car let him pay more for running it. There has to be discrimination between the owner of a Moped and a Bigger Car where the criteria is nothing but affordability.
With so much technology advancement charging according to the kind of vehicle and type of vehicle is possible.

The Income Tax structure in our country is in a similar pattern only, hence this should be possible. The only difference is that the charging has to happen at the time of filling petrol itself. 










No comments:

Post a Comment